patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

UPDATE: Petitions Circulating Against Potential Towson U. White Student Union

A representative for Center for Community Change said more than 700 letters of complaint have been sent to the Towson University president's office.

 

(Update 8:18 p.m.)— A national service organization has called on Towson University President Maravene Loeschke to denounce the creation of a White Student Union on the campus.

"We see this as a racially divisive group, and the news of this was very concerning to the communities that we serve," said Jeff Parcher, director of communications for Center for Community Change.

In an email, Donna De La Cruz, a press secretary for the organization, wrote that more than 700 letters against the White Student Union from a series of petitions on Change.org and SignOn.org have reached Loeschke's office.

The Washington, DC-based organization aims to assist low-income people, especially minorities, in 40 states.

Matthew Heimbach, former president of the now-disbanded student group Youth for Western Civilization, is part of a group of students looking to start the White Student Union on the Towson campus. Youth for Western Civilization sparked national attention when its members allegedly wrote "white pride" in chalk on various parts of the campus.

"To think that someone would be so insensitive to the struggles that minority groups have faced in the country is extremely troubling," wrote a Change.org user identified as Alesia Lucas in one of the online petitions. "This group should have no place on a college campus."

Gay Pinder, a university spokeswoman, said that as of Monday, no paperwork had been filed for a White Student Union. However, she noted that all undergraduate campus-sanctioned groups must welcome all students, provided they have a minimum 2.0 grade point average.

"[Heimbach] may want [the group] to be exclusive to whites, but that's against our policy," Pinder said. "However, it is within his right to form the group—whatever the university thinks of it—as long as it follows the rules."

She declined to comment further stating that because no paperwork has been filed, the group is not yet an issue.

Earlier this year, Loeschke's office formed a task force on bias and discrimination. In March, following the chalking incident, the university held a forum on race issues and safety.

The petition letter can be read in full below:

Dear President Loeschke:

Your University claims that “Towson University values diversity and fosters a climate that is grounded in respect and inclusion, enriches the educational experience of students, supports positive workplace environments, promotes excellence, and cultivates the intellectual and personal growth of the entire university community.”

If the past is any indication, this student group is ploy to exclude groups that have been historically marginalized. A group like this has one goal: to promote hate.

Allowing a “whites only” student group directly contradicts your commitment to diversity -- and it serves no purpose other than to discriminate against non-white students.

As the President of Towson University, I urge you to publically denounce the creation and establishment of the "White Student Union."


Related Topics: Matt Heimbach, Towson University, and White Student Union

Edward

8:33 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

No need to fight for pride when your not doing something shameful. Lets all just follow Jesus who said "They will know your my disciples because you love one another."

Reply
Comment_arrow

Shin

8:40 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

Why does everyone think we have to follow Jesus. You know there are other beliefs out there. I'm arguing with a brick wall of course, so on topic:

Just get rid of all the student unions then. I don't agree with the "White Student Union" but I agree with them bringing to light the fact it's "acceptable" to have Asian Student Unions, Black Student Unions, Latino Student Unions, etc... but suddenly when a "White Student Union" is proposed, everyone goes insane.

I love when complete hypocrisy of a system is made public. So kudos to these guys for that.

JPH

9:27 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

One shouldn't need to follow a higher power to know what is right; opposing this kind of bias is basic humanity. Attempts to further separate us from one another is just plain wrong.

Reply

M. Sullivan

9:30 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

Gee, I wonder how many non-blacks are in the Black Student Union?

Reply
Comment_arrow

nhill

10:41 am on Monday, December 3, 2012

no rasisme against white people , black ave a group now white p can creat group too

CAW21227

10:07 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

My question is, is there a black student union on campus? If there is then the white students have every right to have a student union of their own. As for attempts to further separate us...... I think black people have the market cornered on that one.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Arlow

12:16 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

I think there is. A number of places do- the Firefighters and Police have black groups, there's a black caucus in Congress... seems to me we should be eliminating things that put up barriers.

Comment_arrow

Kaysha

5:19 pm on Friday, September 14, 2012

an you further explain that? Like, I understand that we have a black student union on campus but that's only because there aren't as many black students on campus. Our school is looking for diversity and the majority of students are already WHITE! If the white student union group is about their culture then I will join it. Since, I am more than one race with both white grand parents then I will be joining the white student union! And I would like to see if this is appropriate since I am brown!

Eric

2:29 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

How about we get rid of all these unions and form one new union called "Students who have felt or still feel oppressed due to their race Union". Everyone of all races can all get together and bitch and moan about life and how they been oppressed.

Reply

BlutAusNord

9:03 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

Nobody seems to complain when others form their groups,unions,etc....But when whites form a group they are the second coming of the KKK.Quit whining & get on with life.

Reply

John L.

9:13 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

So just change the words: "whites only" to "blacks only" & there goes your diversity. Such a cry over nothing.

Reply

Mobtown

9:37 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

Does the Black Student Union restrict whites any other students from joining? Does the Asian Student Union restrict only Asians to join? College is about exploration so you may have people of other races joining other groups just because they are interested in issues that affect that group. For what its worth the NAACP has white members.....

Reply

Towson U Student.

9:53 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

Hi, Towson Student here. Yes, there are white members of the BSU (in fact, this semester a member of the board is) and all other organizations are integrated. The issue Towson Students are taking with this issue is, again, Last semester there were issues with Matthew Heimbach and the group that was now disbanded creating issues on campus. Not just to the black student union, but to the Muslim student union, and LGBT-allied orgs. Pure hatred. NO one thinks "white student union = racist", it's just that these PARTICULAR people have a proven track record of being terrible. To the point where minority students feared their safety on campus.

When you look at history and consider WHY Black/Asian/Latino/Muslim/Minority Student Unions DO exist and WERE erected, primarily in Predominantly White Institutions, you'd understand why some are confused by the notion of a "white student union". I feel it's wonderful for all races to be able to celebrate themselves and their culture, but NOT in the name of hatred of another group. Also, the focus of these groups are NOT to "bitch and moan about life and how they been oppressed". Please I encourage all to do your OWN research on groups before you judge and spill from the mouth about them.

Reply

Baltimore Matt

3:21 pm on Friday, September 14, 2012

If you don't like having a white student union, then don't join. Fact is if there is no interest, people won't join and the group will naturally disband once the founding members graduate/lose interest (probably less than 4 years)

To the point people were making against having a white student union, there are many black student organizations at historically African American colleges. If you don't believe me, there are about a dozen at Morgan State http://www.msustudentcenter.com/studentActivities/campusOrgs.asp?pageID=14&SectionID=2.

Furthmore, I don't think any organization for oppressed people is a good idea because it leads to being exclusive to only their own members. If you remember, it was not too long ago minorities of all types (Blacks, Jews, Catholics, Asians, Irish, Pole, etc) could not be members of the same country clubs, live in the same neighborhoods, and work in the same places and the last thing we need are race specific organizations. Therefore they should allow the white student union to exist or disband all racial/religious/gender... organizations

Reply

Dave

9:36 pm on Friday, September 14, 2012

Baltimore Matt as well as others commenting on this article, come on. As the Towson student stated, any student group be it black, asian, lgbt, etc. are open to all Towson students, white or not. Your analogy to country clubs and exclusion holds absolutely no water. You stated, "Furthmore, I don't think any organization for oppressed people is a good idea because it leads to being exclusive to only their own members. If you remember, it was not too long ago minorities of all types (Blacks, Jews, Catholics, Asians, Irish, Pole, etc) could not be members of the same country clubs..." Check me if I'm wrong, but how many black, jewish, asian, catholic, irish, polish, etc, country clubs exist that only allow black, jewish, asian, catholic, irish, polish, etc, members to join. Not many if any. My guess is that the people who are in Baltimore Matt's camp also believe nothing should be categorized as a hate crime? Am I right?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Baltimore Matt

11:10 pm on Friday, September 14, 2012

Dave, then what is the problem with a white student union? Why is it so controversial? If the clubs are open to everyone and that is the rule then blacks, asians, and hispanics can join the white club as well (like the other ethnic/racial clubs). Whether people of other races would want to join is their business.

Comment_arrow

Paul137

5:08 pm on Monday, September 17, 2012

Regarding "hate crimes," if the category exists at all (prominent talk-radio host Larry Elder has asked, "What would a 'love crime' be then?"), it should be applied uniformly.

But it isn't. The rare white-on-minority crimes are trumpeted nationally, while the endemic black-on-everybody-else crimes enjoy the quiet of oblivion.

If "hate crimes" were publicized and prosecuted uniformly on their (de)merits, Dave, you'd be quite familiar with the horrifying details of the Wichita Massacre and the Knoxville Horror (check Wikipedia on both). But you've probably never heard of either. Right?

Dave

8:09 pm on Monday, September 17, 2012

Paul 137
Regarding the Wichita murders, this is from the wiki source that you cited:
“The brothers broke into a house chosen nearly at random where Brad Heyka, Heather Muller, Aaron Sander, Jason Befort and his girlfriend, a young woman identified as 'H.G.', all in their twenties, were spending the night.

Regarding the Knoxville murders, which I had read about prior to your post, this is from the wiki source you cited:
"There is absolutely no proof of a hate crime," said John Gill, special counsel to Knox County District Atty. Randy Nichols. "We know from our investigation that the people charged in this case were friends with white people, socialized with white people, dated white people. So not only is there no evidence of any racial animus, there's evidence to the contrary."[45]

If a bunch of white supremacists drag a black man behind their pickup causing his death, and causing his death specifically because he is black, that is a hate crime. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_James_Byrd,_Jr.

Neither of the cases you cite shows any evidence that the subjects were targeted because of their race or sexual orientation. So I’ll ask again, do you just not believe in hate crimes?

Regarding the ridiculous "love crime" comment, murders and beatings are awful, but not always rooted in someone's race, or sexual orientation. When they fall in that category, they are hate crimes.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Paul137

12:20 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Dave, the enhancement of criminality because of what a perp was thinking when he (or she) did it is ridiculous. So, yes, the category of "hate crime" is ridiculous.

The point about Wichita and Knoxville is that they received zero national attention. Flip the races of the perps and victims, and the news stories would have numbered in the hundreds of thousands at the least. Plus whatever the other **actual** particulars, they would have been labeled "hate crimes."

Regarding James Byrd, sure his murder was unspeakably horrific. And when blacks did something very similar to Ken Tillery, a white, in the same town (Jasper, TX) a few years later, the national silence was overwhelming. (Pertinent article by Larry Elder, who is black: http://capitalismmagazine.com/2002/03/politically-correct-murder-and-media-bias-some-murder-victims-are-more-equal-than-others/ )

But if what the perp was thinking when he did it is important to you, Dave, then add in the fact that one of the perps in the Byrd murder had been repeatedly raped by blacks when he was previously in prison.

Dave

10:06 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Paul,
I think the issue with hate crimes, at least racially motivated hate crimes, is that white people haven't been strung up by their necks because they are white, unlike black people. As a side note Clarence Thomas is black, so is Thomas Sowell (cited in one of your wiki articles), but I think I'm blacker than both of them.

Reply

Jamesup

11:57 pm on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

With regard to ethnic and racial unions it is reasonable that they exist, just as there are Catholic, Baptist, Jewish, and Mormon groups. Of course such groups would have members that had interest in closer association with persons of their own religious interests; in consequence eventhough there were persons of differing persuasions, there likely wouldn't be significant numbers. This idea demonstrates Hitler's error. The Jews were almost exclusively interested in there own for marriage and close association; so if their theories weren't satisfactory, the other Germans who vastly outnumbered them could simply reject them. There was no need to exterminate them. If people of any race, religion, or ethnic construction find that they enjoy close association in a permitted union, they constitutionally are allowed to do so. They should not be criticized as long as they don't disrespect other groups.

Reply

s

7:32 pm on Monday, November 12, 2012

When you visit all the sites discussing this subject what you find is out of every 10,000 people replying 9,999 people support them. like it or not eventually this will happen.if not by this group another will succeed you can discriminate against white people for ever.

Reply

nhill

10:49 am on Monday, December 3, 2012

I m BLACK me ,and I FUCK THIS PETITION

Reply

Leave a comment