Trash the Trash Tax

Trashing the tax trash idea.

Mayor Rawlings-Blake is proposing charging Baltimore City residents a "fee" for trash collection.  The idea is that if we have to start paying a "fee" to have our trash collected that somehow this will enable the city to reduce the property tax and thus attract more people to move here.

The assumption is that somehow we have been getting our trash collected for free all these years.  Who would have thunk it?

The fact is that Baltimore City residents pay for their services through property taxes, local taxes, and a whole lot of other "fees" that can be found on our telephone, cable, and water bills.  

So let's get this notion that we have been getting some kind of bargain on trash collection out of the way right now.

According to the Baltimore Sun, the Mayor said many areas surrounding the city have fees for trash collection that are not part of their property taxes.

Well, that is not entirely accurate.

I checked with Howard and Anne Arundel counties and while both counties do charge separately for trash collection, they both include the fees on the yearly property tax statements.

You can call it a "fee" or a "tax," but either way, there it is on the bill. 

Also, residents in Anne Arundel County can opt-out of having the county collect their trash, if a majority of residents in a community agree.

Is the Mayor going to seriously propose that city residents can opt-out of trash collection?  I mean, some people apparently already do opt-out, but will this be a city policy?

But the most glaring problem with the Mayor's plan is that Baltimore City trash collectors are union city employees (AFSCME Local Council 67).  Both Howard and Anne Arundel counties contract their trash collection out.  (I could not get a definitive answer on whether the actual sanitation workers are county employees or union, but I suspect not.)

Again, does Mayor Rawlings-Blake really think the city can compete with the surrounding areas on the cost to collecting trash while keeping the sanitation workers on as city employees at union wages?

I doubt it can be done.

And, an even more intriguing question is, will Mayor Rawlings-Blake actually jettison AFSCME Local Council 67, who supported her during her mayoral campaign and contract out the city trash collection?  Again, I think not (and I hope not).

The fact is that in order for Baltimore City to seriously compete with the surrounding counties we would have to fire all the sanitation workers who collect our trash and contract the services out.  Otherwise I don't see how adding a fee for a service we already pay for in taxes is going to lower those said taxes.  It just isn't logical.

So, I am calling this proposed "fee" what is really is - a Trash Tax.

I also have my doubts that we'll actually see property taxes reduced based on the Trash Tax.  And, remember, once the Trash Tax is imposed, they can (and will) raise it.

The only way I will be sold on this idea is if our property tax is reduced immediately and in proportion to whatever the Trash tax is.

I do have one alternative the mayor hasn't mentioned.  Instead of adding a new Trash Tax, or fee, or whatever you want to call it, why not just make it a goal to lower property taxes by, say, thirty cents over ten years, instead of the proposed fifty cents?  Either way, the taxes and fees city residents pay will still be astronomically higher than the surrounding areas and they will continue to sufficiently keep people moving into other jurisdiction other than Baltimore City.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Sean Tully February 22, 2013 at 08:16 PM
Able, I am not unfamiliar with what Daniel is saying. But what he is saying is irrelevant to this discussion since our recycling is not free. Now, if you want to discuss whether or not Baltimore City should have the same type of trash collection that Aberdeen has, I'll be happy to engage you.
Sean Tully February 22, 2013 at 08:17 PM
I totally agree that the city has to step up enforcement. But try and get the city to listen.
Christian February 24, 2013 at 02:30 PM
Dave, Sean Tully and Able Baker, believe me there is a great deal you can do about this issue. A neighbor of ours in CV has actually gotten the interest of the City, Council Representatives and the offenders who refuse to act as prudent homeowners, renters and businesses. What we have been doing is monitoring properties and reporting each week to our elected officials, the City's agencies and documenting each complaint by a photographic summary of what has been noted. While there has not been dramatic changes made, we are creating a successful stream of actions that are causing these groups of buildings to take care of their garbage issues in a responsible manner. We hope to establish a "Code of Ethics" with the various buildings that show responsible management of garbage and which outlines the consequences of not following through. Dave, with respect to Drugs, you should contact the Northern District Police Department and explain the situation and report the disturbing the peace as well. These problems can be resolved if all of us want to get involved in actually supporting our claims with evidence and continued monitoring. We have also written to the Mayor and in some respects to the President of JHU who owns some of the buildings in order to establish guidelines, via our proposed "Code of Ethics". There is hope and we just have to work to ensure we get the attention of those in power to correct it. Good luck.
Able Baker February 25, 2013 at 07:06 PM
You're being intentionally obtuse by quibbling over the use of the word "free". Daniel is clearly talking about recycling that's free to the consumer as opposed to trash collection that's paid by volume.
Able Baker February 25, 2013 at 07:09 PM
That's not exactly true. If you compare Charles Village to other neighborhoods, there are a lot more trash cans. CV bought the trash cans and services them. They don't generally empty City cans.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »